Investors have seen supermarkets and grocers increasing in value since the bidding war for Morrisons began, where private equity companies such as CD&R, Fortress and Apollo have either bid or expressed an interest in the supermarket chain.
With the recent purchase of ASDA by the Issa brothers, there are increased fears that these changes could potentially lead to the breakup of the UK’s Big Four and lead to insecurity of food, inequality, and reduction of workers’ rights. What could the impacts be once the bidding war for Morrisons is over, and how will the takeover change the grocer industry?
An overview
Initially, the US investment firm
Apollo Global Management, considered making an offer but later backed down to
join forces
with rival
Fortress Investment Group. This consortium allowed them to raise
£6.7bn, increasing their previous bid of
£6.3bn.
On the 19th of August, Morrisons agreed on a takeover offer of
£7bn
by the New York private equity firm Clayton, Dubilier & Rice (CD&R). This puts CD&R’s offer at 285p a share, trumping Fortress’ lower offer of 272p per share.
What is happening now?
Some investors have previously rejected a 254p
share offer and started to welcome Fortress’ increased offer of 272p of share before Morrisons received the current bid of £7bn from CD&R. However, Fortress has advised
the Morrisons board to ‘take no action’ as they plan to release further information “in due course”. This has raised speculation that the UK retailer could receive an even higher bid from the Canadian investment firm.
Fears over US buyer and the impact on UK's food supply chain
Environment Secretary,
Luke Pollard, has previously expressed his worries and questioned the binding of voluntary pledges by Fortress and how it will be enforced.
The Labour MP reviewed the takeover, suggesting that they properly examine the commitments, so that jobs and workers’ rights can be protected and maintain the UK's food security.
'If Morrisons is broken up and pieces of it sold for a quick buck, that could potentially weaken the supply chain and Britain's
food security.'
How will this affect Morrison’s workers?
Morrisons is unique, being one of the
‘Big Four’
supermarkets that owns most of their own supply chain with nearly
500
shops and more than 110,000 staff. The discussion of a debt-fuelled private equity takeover by CD&R have caused unions and politicians to
grow weary. They fear that companies could be stripped of their property holdings that come with such a large amount of debt, leading to the deterioration of worker conditions and benefits.
The concern over worker pensions is continuing to grow, especially after the UK saw scandals like Sir Phillip Green’s £1 sale of BHS created a hole in the company’s pension scheme, forcing him to resolve the issue by shelling out an extra £363m.
CD&R
have addressed the worry surrounding pensions,
stating
that if the sale is successful, the pension rights of all Morrisons’ management team and employees will be “fully safeguarded”. During CD&R’s first discussions with Morrisons’ trustees, the investment firm agreed to provide additional security to current pension schemes through an appropriate mitigation package.
ASDA
The shift towards online shopping during the pandemic has made it more attractive for acquisition groups to look towards the supermarket sector.
In October last year, the Issa brothers bought ASDA for
£6.8bn
along with the private equity company TDR, who among other plans was to improve their online business.
The brothers have agreed to sell nearly 30 petrol stations
from the Asda and EG Group in order to conciliate with the Competition and Markets Authority, avoiding an investigation into a £6.8bn deal.
TDR Capital and the brothers co-own the petrol station operator, EG Group, with over
395
UK petrol stations owned by the Issa brothers in comparison to ASDA’s 323. According to the CMA’s senior director Joel Bamford, this could lead to higher prices for motorists in certain parts of the UK.
Retail share increase
Tesco’s
shares increased of
5.9%
to 234.75p since the Morrisons’ takeover interest was first revealed on the 19th of June. Shares of Marks & Spencer have also gone up by
5.4%
to 156.65p in the same period, with grocery considered the group’s key
sales growth
driver.
However, the supermarket chain that saw the highest rise was Sainsburys, increasing from
7.3%
to 279.1p.
Will Sainsburys be next?
“
Sainsbury’s
is the second most attractive target,” according to Equity Analyst,
Ioannis Pontikis
at Morningstar.
There have been speculations on whether or not Sainsbury’s could be sold. Especially since Daniel Kretinsky, the owner of Vesa Equity Investments, increased his company’s stake to
9.99%
at Morrisons.
When looking at Tesco, the retailer is too big, and their profit margin improvements are not considered high. Sainsbury’s has less
stores than its rivals, which is one of the main attractions for private equity bidders. The retail market has grown very competitive with discounters at one end, and Amazon
at another.
Sainsbury’s stores offer more for shoppers; their integration with
Argos
makes the retailer more attractive. Since November, Sainsbury’s announced a restructure that would see the closure of
420
Argos stores and
3,500 job losses
as a result. This change creates a stronger focus on food, home delivery, lowering prices and mini-Argos shops within Sainsbury’s.
Deterrents for potential bidders is actuarial deficit in pensions within the company. Another disincentive is the price match campaign Sainsbury’s has embarked on along with Tesco, which matches prices with discount retailers, Lidl and Aldi, to maintain and attract new shoppers during the pandemic. Continuously lowering prices is not positive in the private equity environment.
However, the shift to online shopping has given Sainsbury’s some advantages over discounters.
What’s to come?
Fears from customers surrounding their weekly shop for groceries have remained prevalent over the last couple of years. Concerns have grown for workers at Morrisons and members regarding pension schemes, support for their local communities, partner suppliers and farmers. The effect the takeover will have on the UK’s supply chain will depend on the promises
made by Morrison’s new owners and regulators ensuring that the agreed commitments are being actioned.